The shoreline in ultra-luxe Nantucket is being battered and beaches in front of multi-million dollar homes are being seriously eroded. Some houses are being moved back from the brink at seven figures in costs. Some have collapsed. Efforts to pipe in sand from elsewhere have been rebuffed.
Daily we hear of wildfires destroying homes, flooding submerging homes, mudslides overwhelming homes. People use their insurance if they have any and it applies (earthquake insurance isn’t an easy purchase in California), rebuild if they can, and try to start over.
All of this, in the face of a clearly changing climate, is contingent action. It’s like praising the sprinkler system even though the fire was dreadful, or being happy the lifejackets kept you afloat as the boat sank. The sprinklers and lifejackets saved lives, but wouldn’t it be more effective to prevent the harm of the fire or the boat sinking?
We need to stop building homes and communities on the peripheries of (or inside) forests and along seacoasts, as examples. Too many people have done this, seen their homes destroyed, rebuilt using insurance money, and then experienced that destruction a second (or third) time. “We’re going to rebuild!” is a nice sign of determination and resilience, but if it’s in the same spot it’s also a sign of intransigence and selfishness. Police, fire, and emergency services lose people every year trying to save others who shouldn’t be where they are.
We need flood-resistant housing, in any case. (There are such things.) We need earthquake-resistant and fire-resistant housing. (There are such things.) I had a client who must remain confidential who is working on self-sustaining homes that recycle everything and actually contribute excess power to the existing grid, making a profit in the process. (There will be such things.)
It’s preventive action that we need to focus on, to start boasting about anticipating and saving, not rebuilding and reconstructing.
Nantucket will eventually look very different. After all, it’s an island in a four-season area of the Atlantic Ocean. It was once a whaling center, from whence its wealth originated, over two centuries ago. But that has changed.
All things do.
|